Look at the dirt – quick tips for authenticating neolithic and ancient Chinese pottery

real verse fake chinese porcelain-earthenware-ceamic-terracotta

Super quick post regarding a recent discussion I was having about cleaning antiquities, particularly those which would have been buried underground. While there are many highly specialized and scientific ways to authenticate a piece (for example TL testing), there are also some very practical clues one can look out for. For example dirt. When an item has been buried underground for millenia, the soil itself will likely take on certain characteristics, which are easily seen when compared to some of the more obvious fakes. There are differences in climates to account for but a general rule is that dirt does not equate to age. Fakers, particularly in the case of lower end fakes, will opt for lots of dirt under the assumption that the uninitiated buyer will equate dirt with age. This is particularly true with pottery, earthenware and ceramics, though holds true to a degree with furniture as well. So lets quickly compare the soil compacted on the surfaces of both an authentic piece and an obvious reproduction.

real verse fake chinese porcelain-earthenware-ceamic-terracotta

The fake on the left is about 2 years old. The jar on the right is about 2000 years old. Notice the extreme differences in the soil compacted on the surface of each jar? The fake has had mud compacted on its surface to simulate burial. Its dry, crumbly and peals away easily leaving little residue.  It feels more like its been sunk into a muddy field for a short period of time, rather then in a tomb for several thousand years. The one on the right is covered in a thick, very finely compacted build up of hard soil. Nor does it crack away easily. This is the product of gradual build up over a very long period of time. Its completely dried out, yet extremely dense and does not remove easily.

Related Books & Reading

No More Fake Reading: Merging the Classics With Independent Reading to Create Joyful, Lifelong Readers (Corwin Literacy)No More Fake Reading: Merging the Classics With Independent Reading to Create Joyful, Lifelong Readers (Corwin Literacy)Discover the Right Mix of Choice Reading and the Classics

How do you motivate students with little appetite for classic literature to stop ... Read More >
Fake Science: Exposing the Left's Skewed Statistics, Fuzzy Facts, and Dodgy DataFake Science: Exposing the Left's Skewed Statistics, Fuzzy Facts, and Dodgy DataIf you listen to any political argument, you're eventually bound to hear something like: "The science is settled on this." Or: "Just look at the stati... Read More >

1 Comment

  1. […] Antiquities trade professional Roger Schwendeman explained: ‘Fakers, particularly in the case of lower end fakes, will opt for [applying] lots of dirt under the assumption that the uninitiated buyer will equate dirt with age.’ […]

Leave a Reply